Adjusting capital gains for inflation, a proposal aimed at taxing only ‘real’ appreciation, could offer benefits to long-term investors by reducing tax burdens on gains solely due to rising prices. However, experts caution that implementing such a system would introduce significant complexities for individual investors, especially concerning assets like real estate and varying investment strategies like dollar-cost averaging.
While the idea of taxing only true economic gains is appealing, the administrative burden and potential for confusion, particularly with losses and diverse asset types, make its passage uncertain. The Tax Foundation suggests that higher-income individuals would benefit most, raising questions about equity.
READ MORE FROM CNBC
A proposed tax adjustment to account for inflation when calculating capital gains, while sounding beneficial, could create significant administrative hurdles for individual investors. The concept, which aims to tax only the 'real' appreciation of assets rather than gains inflated by rising prices, has resurfaced as a potential legislative idea.
Cary Sinnett, a certified financial planner and director of personal financial planning at the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, explains that indexing capital gains would adjust an asset's basis for inflation. This means taxes would be applied to the actual economic gain, not just the increase in value attributed to inflation. For instance, if an investor bought a stock for $100 and it's now worth $102 with 2% inflation, under current rules, they'd pay taxes on the full $2 gain. With inflation adjustment, the tax would be on a smaller, 'real' gain.
The current tax structure includes a top long-term capital gains rate of 20%, plus a 3.8% net investment income tax for higher earners. Short-term gains are taxed at ordinary income rates, potentially as high as 37%. Sinnett notes that while the idea seems straightforward, 'there are some substantial complexities.'
Incentivizing Long-Term Investing
Long-term investors stand to benefit the most. An asset held for a decade might see significant inflation compound, leading to a more substantial inflation adjustment compared to an asset sold after just over a year. 'It's great for the long-term investor,' Sinnett states. 'You're more likely going to see a cultural push to hold, and get that step-up for inflation.' This could also encourage investors to rebalance portfolios, as the fear of capital gains tax consequences often leads them to hold onto highly appreciated assets. However, an analysis from the Tax Foundation suggests that the highest income households would see the most significant financial benefits, with a modest increase for lower quintiles.
The Trade-Off: Complexity Over Simplicity
The practical application of inflation adjustments across a wide range of investments poses challenges. While brokerage firms might handle calculations for many assets, others like collectibles, real estate, or private company shares would likely fall to the individual taxpayer. Tim Steffen, CPA and director of advanced planning at Baird, points out that complexities arise with methods like dollar-cost averaging, where investors buy assets at regular intervals. Tracking the adjusted cost basis becomes difficult. Similarly, dividend reinvestments could add to the calculation burden. Furthermore, when an asset is sold at a loss, the inflation adjustment could potentially turn a realized loss into a smaller loss or even an artificial gain, complicating tax reporting.
Unlikely to Materialize Soon
Despite the potential benefits, the implementation of inflation-adjusted capital gains is considered unlikely to gain traction soon. Garrett Watson, vice president of federal tax policy at the Tax Foundation, believes a comprehensive approach is needed, and the political window for such a change may have already closed. Democrats are reportedly skeptical due to the potential loss of government revenue. The Treasury and IRS would face significant administrative challenges in processing these adjustments. The article references related content on Treasury yields and strategies for managing tax bills, highlighting the ongoing investor focus on tax efficiency.
