Four major high-yield savings accounts from Apple, Ally Financial, Capital One, and Marcus by Goldman Sachs recently cut their rates, lowering the peer median to 3.4%. This move is unexpected given the Federal Reserve’s steady rates and market expectations for no immediate Fed cuts, with some traders even predicting future increases.
Analysts are puzzled, citing potential reasons like slowing loan growth or increased competition from new bank approvals. Despite these cuts, savers can still earn a 4% APY on high-yield savings accounts with Bread Financial and LendingClub, with Bread Financial also offering 4% on 1-year CDs, which lock in rates but carry early withdrawal penalties.
READ MORE FROM CNBC
In a move that has surprised financial analysts, four prominent high-yield savings accounts recently slashed their interest rates. This comes at a time when the market generally does not anticipate the Federal Reserve to implement rate cuts in the near future. The affected accounts, managed by major financial institutions including Apple, Ally Financial, Capital One Financial, and Marcus by Goldman Sachs, all saw reductions over the past week. Consequently, the peer median savings rate has dipped by 5 basis points, now standing at 3.4%, according to a report from BTIG.
Historically, yields on savings accounts are often benchmarked against the federal funds rate. A reduction by the central bank typically prompts a similar response from commercial banks. However, the Fed has maintained its rates since last December. Persistent elevated inflation and a surprisingly robust jobs report from last week have effectively pushed back expectations for any rate reductions this year. Some market participants are even beginning to price in the possibility of rate increases later in the year, as indicated by the CME FedWatch tool.
Vincent Caintic, a specialty finance analyst at BTIG, voiced his confusion in a recent note: "We're candidly unsure what to make of deposit rate cuts, with the market probabilities calling for one [quarter point] Fed rate hike in December 2026." Caintic theorized that a potential slowdown in loan growth might be diminishing the demand for deposits, although he observed that recent competitor financial conferences have not suggested a widespread deceleration in loan growth.
Conversely, Caintic also highlighted that some online banks are anticipating heightened competition for deposits, partly due to the Trump administration's expedited approval of new bank applications. "[T]his would make us surprised at significant deposit rate cuts at this time," he added.
Despite these recent rate adjustments, opportunities for savers to earn a competitive 4% annual percentage yield (APY) still exist. Currently, two online banks, Bread Financial and LendingClub, are maintaining a 4% APY on their high-yield savings accounts. Furthermore, Bread Financial also offers a 4% APY on its 1-year certificates of deposit (CDs). Most other 1-year CDs covered by BTIG's research offer yields below 4%.
A key advantage of CDs is their ability to lock in a guaranteed interest rate for the entire duration of the certificate, providing protection against future rate declines. However, it's crucial for depositors to be aware that withdrawing funds before a CD matures can result in penalties.
